Get Permission Rasool, Showkat, Farooq, and Gani: Exploring the correlation between attendance and academic performance in physiology among phase 1st MBBS students: A comprehensive study


Introduction

Since the inception of the formal education system, offline classroom teaching has been the sole method in schools and colleges. Punctuality to classes has been considered a major indicator of performance, leading governing bodies to establish rules for minimum compulsory attendance to ensure the quality of education remains high. Attendance and punctuality serve as important reflections of professional engagement. In medical school, punctuality and participation instill habits crucial for future clinicians. The vast curriculum of MBBS and high stakes have led universities and regulatory bodies to emphasize attendance policies. Many universities set 75% as the cutoff for exam eligibility. Student absenteeism, especially in the 1st MBBS with reduced duration, poses a challenge, emphasizing the importance of attendance in building foundational knowledge. During the undergraduate curriculum, attendance plays a vital role in extrapolating knowledge for later professional life. Active learning formats dominate learner classroom time, with participation essential for individual and peer learning. Numerous studies have shown a positive correlation between attendance and student performance1, 2, 3, 4 though some suggest that class attendance might not be a reliable marker for performance, especially in theory.5 College attendance, facilitating interaction with teachers and peers, is viewed as a prime factor in shaping the personality of young doctors, potentially reflecting in their performance. The COVID era significantly impacted the education sector, prompting the closure of institutes and a shift to online education. Despite its pros and cons, online education played a crucial role, saving about two academic years during the pandemic. As COVID-related restrictions eased, institutes resumed offline education, maintaining appropriate behavior. This study aims to explore the impact of this mixed teaching approach—combining online and offline methods—on students' academic performance in both theoretical and practical aspects.

Aim and Objective

The study aimed to evaluate the previously unexplored correlation between undergraduate medical students' attendance, learning preferences, and their academic performance. It also sought to investigate any differences in the attendance rates between male and female students and determine whether such differences, if present, impact academic performance. This research was conducted in the Department of Physiology.

Materials and Methods

A retrospective cohort study was conducted on 198 first-year MBBS students from the 2019-20 batches who participated in both three internal examinations and the final University examination in both theory and practicals. These students were selected from the Department of Physiology at GMC Baramulla. After obtaining Institutional ethical clearance, attendance records were meticulously maintained. In-person signature sheets were used during offline classes, while the MS Teams app's in-built attendance system tracked attendance during online classes. For internal assessments, a variety of exams, including multiple quizzes, two terminals, and a final golden test, were conducted throughout the year. The collected data was entered into MS Excel and categorized into two groups based on attendance percentage. In theory, students with less than 75% attendance were placed in group A, while those with 75% or more were assigned to group B. Regarding practicals, students with less than 80% attendance constituted group A, while those with 80% or more comprised group B. This categorization aligned with the NMC's minimum attendance eligibility criteria for university exams. Additionally, data was separated based on gender and whether the student was a hosteler or not, allowing for the examination of possible gender and accommodation-related variations. The data was then analyzed in the same Excel sheet using the Karl Pearson correlation coefficient to assess the strength of the association between students' attendance and internal assessment marks. Statistical significance was determined using the Student T test, with a p-value less than 0.05 considered significant.

Results & Discussion

Table 1

Correlation between attendance vs marks in theory combined

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.25

64

41

<0.01

B

0.22

84

45

<0.01

Table 2

Correlation between attendance vs marks in practical combined

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.2

65

56

<0.01

B

0.02

89

57

<0.01

Table 3

Correlation between attendance vs marks in theory among males

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.4

64

41

<0.01

B

0.4

84

47

<0.01

Table 4

Correlation between attendance vs marks in practical among males

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.3

65

54

<0.01

B

-0.4

87

57

<0.01

Table 5

Correlation between attendance vs marks in theory among females

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.03

65

40

<0.01

B

0.1

84

45

<0.01

Table 6

Correlation between attendance vs marks in practicals among females

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

P value

Mean

Marks

A

0.07

66

58

<0.01

B

0.2

91

57

<0.01

Table 7

Table G correlation between attendance vs marks in theory among hostelers

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.22

62

38

<0.01

B

0.25

84

45

<0.01

Table 8

Table G correlation between attendance vs marks in practicals among hostelers

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

0.32

62

55

<0.01

B

-0.08

89

57

<0.01

Table 9

Table G correlation between attendance vs marks in theory among non-hostelers

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

-0.2

69

46

<0.01

B

0.2

85

45

<0.01

Table 10

Table G correlation between attendance vs marks in practicals among non-hostelers

Group

Correlation coefficient: attendance vs marks

Mean

P value

Attendance

Marks

A

-0.050

69

57

<0.01

B

0.15

89

58

<0.01

Previous studies have shown a positive but weak correlation between attendance percentage and academic outcome.6 While several confounding factors may affect academic outcome, class attendance has consistently demonstrated a relationship with cognitive ability and academic performance in students.3 Studies on the effect of mandatory attendance policies within medical schools are sparse, though one study indicated that a mandatory attendance policy increased attendance without a corresponding increase in academic outcomes in Basic Sciences lectures.7

Our study aligns with multiple previous studies, revealing a statistically significant positive correlation between attendance and internal assessment marks in both theory and practicals. Group A showed a stronger correlation compared to Group B, suggesting that beyond a certain point (here being 75% in theory and 80% in practicals), increased attendance may not significantly impact scores. With an increase in the mean attendance percentage, mean marks also increased. (Table 1, Table 2) According to Richard P. Deane et al., attendance at OBG clinical and tutorial-based activities positively correlated with overall examination scores.1, 8, 9, 10, 11 Additionally, Sangeeta M. and Varalakshmi K. L., in their study in the Department of Anatomy, concluded that there is a significant positive correlation between class attendance and academic achievement.2 Our study supports their findings.Concerning gender (Table 3, Table 4, Table 5, Table 6), in contrast to a study by Sangeeta M. and Varalakshmi K. L., who found male students less likely to attend classes,2 our study did not show much difference in the average attendance percentage between theory and practicals. Hamidi Al Shenawni et al. concluded that no significant difference was observed in academic performance between female and male students.12 In our study, males scored slightly better in theory, while females excelled in practicals. However, a positive correlation between class attendance and academic achievement was maintained. Among males, a stronger positive correlation was noted between attendance and scores obtained compared to their female counterparts, with the exception being Group B males (above 80% attendance in practicals), showing a significant negative correlation. This could be due to differences in hours of self-learning among students in addition to regular classes in this group. However, this does not undermine the importance of strict attendance rules in medical colleges, as the mean attendance in this group was approximately 87%. We also explored the difference between hostelers and non-hostelers (Table 7, Table 8, Table 9, Table 10), discovering that, contrary to common notions, non-hostellers were, on average, more regular in classes than hostellers, positively reflecting in their average scores. This might be attributed to parental pressure among non-hostellers to attend classes regularly. In hostellers, positive correlation was noted in both theory and practicals, except in Group B hostellers, where a weak negative correlation was observed. Non-hostellers displayed varied results among different groups, warranting further study, especially considering a majority of non-hostellers being from the open merit category. NEET scores need to be considered before drawing conclusions. Class attendance was not associated with improved academic performance in a dermatology course. Those who preferred to learn by watching online videos demonstrated a higher level of performance than those who did not prefer this method.13 The most frequently cited reason for attending classes was social expectation (96%), whereas the least cited was learning well in a classroom-type setting (65%). The top reasons cited by students for not attending classes were the availability of lectures online (35%), a preference for individual study outside the classroom setting (26%), and the inconvenience of traveling to class (24%). Multivariate analysis found no statistically significant relationship between class attendance and performance on the final examination (estimate -0.074, standard error 0.12; p = 0.54), after adjusting for sex, age, Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) score, having children at home, and reason for attending class. Those who preferred to learn by watching online videos scored significantly higher on the final examination (prefer online videos: 87 ± 5.5; neutral: 86 ± 5.9; do not prefer online videos: 82 ± 2.6 [P = 0.049]).14, 15 Our study is not without limitations, as only a few known confounding factors were taken into consideration, such as gender and accommodation, unlike factors like cognitive ability, cultural, social, and economic conditions of students, which were ignored.

Conclusions

This study concludes that there is a significant positive association between attendance and the performance of students in both theory and practical aspects of physiology among Phase 1st MBBS students.1, 2, 3, 4 The correlation is stronger below the NMC guidelines for minimum attendance. This finding aligns with the study by BS Subramaniam et al., which revealed that the implementation of an attendance policy improves exam performance by 7%.4 Additionally, Goyal et al. conducted the Assessment of Competency Based Medical Internship Training with the 'Cumulative Grade Points Average System.11 Therefore, a strict attendance monitoring system should be implemented in medical colleges, and parents should regularly be informed about their ward's absenteeism, especially for hostelers. Moreover, online classes have not significantly impacted this relationship.

Source of Funding

None.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

RP Deane DJ Murphy Student attendance and academic performance in undergraduate obstetrics/gynecology clinical rotationsJAMA20133102122828

2 

M Sangeeta KL Varalakshmi Association between class attendance and internal assessment marks in anatomyIndian J Clin Anat Physiol2019613840

3 

LK Mohanan DT Harichandran SM Vijayan Association of class attendance and academic performance of MBBS students in pharmacology - A retrospective cohort studyNatl J Physiol Pharm Pharmacol2017710105660

4 

BS Subramaniam S Hande R Komattil Attendance and achievement in medicine: Investigating the impact of attendance policies on academic performance of medical studentsAnn Med Health Sci Res2013322025

5 

CA Kauffman M Derazin A Asmar JD Kibble Relationship between classroom attendance and examination performance in a second-year medical pathophysiology classAdv Physiol Educ20184245938

6 

RP Deane DJ Murphy Student attendance and academic performance in Undergraduate Obstetrics/Gynecology Clinical RotationsJAMA20133102122828

7 

DH Cohall D Skeete The impact of an attendance policy on the academic performance of first year medical students taking the fundamental of Disease and treatment courseCarribean Teaching Sch20122211523

8 

KS Chilwant JC Hundekari Effect of class attendance on performance in second year medical studentsIOSR J Res Method Educ201333313

9 

M Varul A Vegad C Shah Attendance attitudes and academic performance: A study on First year MBBS students attending Physiology classesInt J Med Sci Educ201631317

10 

RM Schmidt Who maximizes what ? A study in student time allocationAm Econ Rev1983732238

11 

M Crede GR Sylvia M Urszula Keiszczynca Class attendance in college: A meta analytic review of the relationship of class attendance with grades and student characteristicsRev Educl Res201080227295

12 

HA Shenawi R Yaghan A Almarabheh N AlShenawi The relationship between attendance and academic performance of undergraduate medical students during surgical clerkshipBMC Med Educ2021211396

13 

RC Goyal S Choudhari SR Tankhiwale Assessment of Competency BasedMedical Internship Training with ‘Cumulative Grade Points Average System’-An Innovative Steptowards Meeting ‘Vision 2015’ of Medical Council of IndiaIndian J Public Health Res Dev20189815562

14 

YL Khan SK Lodhi S Bhatti W Ali Does Absenteeism Affect Academic Performance Among Undergraduate Medical Students? Evidence From “Rashid Latif Medical College (RLMC).”Adv Med Educ Pract2019109991008

15 

L Wang Z Yu Gender-moderated effects of academic self-concept on achievement, motivation, performance, and self-efficacy: A systematic reviewFront Psychol. 2023; 14: 202314113614110.3389/fpsyg.2023.1136141



jats-html.xsl


This is an Open Access (OA) journal, and articles are distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 License, which allows others to remix, tweak, and build upon the work non-commercially, as long as appropriate credit is given and the new creations are licensed under the identical terms.

  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 08-12-2023

Accepted : 20-12-2023


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijcap.2023.053


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 1455

PDF Downloaded: 257