Rajan: Study of variations in the anterior half of the circle of Willis using magnetic resonance angiography


Introduction

The circle of Willis is an arterial anastomosis at the base of the brain that unites the internal carotid and vertebro-basilar arteries.1 Anteriorly, the anterior cerebral arteries, branches of internal carotid, are connected by anterior communicating artery, and posteriorly, the posterior cerebral artery, one on each side arising from basilar artery, is joined to the ipsilateral internal carotid by posterior communicating artery. Clinicians frequently divide the intracranial vasculature2 into an anterior circulation consisting of intradural internal carotid and its two terminal branches, namely anterior cerebral and middle cerebral arteries, and the anterior communicating artery, and a posterior circulation comprising of posterior communicating arteries, vertebro-basilar trunk and the terminal branches of basilar artery, the two posterior cerebral arteries.

In the anterior part, the anterior cerebral artery (ACA) arises from the medial aspect of the internal carotid artery bifurcation, below the anterior perforated substance, at the medial end of the stem of the lateral sulcus. It courses antero-medially towards the inter-hemispheric fissure, separated by the falx cerebri, above the optic chiasma or optic nerve. At the level of the inter-hemispheric fissure, it is joined to the contralateral anterior cerebral artery via, the short transverse anterior communicating artery (ACoA) in the supra-chiasmatic cistern.

Surgical nomenclature2, 3, 4 divides the anterior cerebral artery (ACA) into three parts:

  1. A1 (horizontal) segment extending from the internal carotid artery bifurcation to the anterior communicating artery.

  2. A2 (vertical) segment extending from the junction with anterior communicating artery to the origin of callosomarginal artery (junction of the rostrum and genu of the corpus callosum).

  3. A3 (callosal) segment distal to the origin of callosomarginal artery (extending around the genu until the artery turns sharply posteriorly, also called pericallosal artery).

To understand the variants in the circle of Willis observed during cerebral angiography, an understanding of its development is essential. The embryological development of the cranial arterial vasculature in its adult form evolves in early foetal life through a number of simultaneous/ overlapping steps. The third aortic arch is the precursor5, 6 of the primitive internal carotid artery, which gives off cranial and caudal divisions that form the anterior cerebral and posterior communicating arteries respectively (also giving off anterior choroidal and middle cerebral arteries).

There are considerable individual variations in the pattern and calibre of vessels that make up the circulus arteriosus. The cerebral and communicating arteries may be individually absent, variably hypoplastic, double, or even triple. Widespread clinical interest in the arterial circle is due to its propensity for variations relevant for neurosurgical, vascular and radiological interventional procedures especially with regard to cerebrovascular accidents.

Materials and Methods

The study design is an observational descriptive study over a period of 18 months conducted by the department of Anatomy in coordination with department of Radio-Diagnosis at Pushpagiri Institute of Medical Sciences & Research Centre, Tiruvalla. The investigative modality for the study was magnetic resonance angiography (MRA) of the brain. Cerebral imaging was performed on a 1.5T MRI machine including axial T1, T2, and FLAIR (fluid attenuation inversion recovery) weighted sequences. Circle of Willis MRA was performed using three-dimensional (3D) time-off flight (TOF) sequence. The original MRA sequence for each patient is retrieved from an electronic database (DXMMR). The 215 subjects for the MRA study were taken up from those availing this investigation as part of their clinical workup or follow-up at the institute, on in-patient or outpatient basis. All MRAs of brain conducted in the institution on adults of both sexes in the age group between 18 and 90 years were included in the study. Those excluded were images with evidence of Neurosurgical interventions (AVM repair, shunting), known or diagnosed cases of vasculopathies such as arteritis, and known craniofacial anomalies and genetic disorders.

Results

In the present study of angiograms of 215 consecutive subjects who underwent MR angiography at our institute, the number of morphologically complete circle of Willis was 135 (62.79%). The textbook type Circle of Willis with complete anterior and posterior circulations was observed in 86 images (40% of total images); this formed 63.7% of the complete arterial circles. Incomplete arterial circles comprised 80 of the total 215 images (37.21%). The anterior circulation was functionally complete in 200 images, of which 86 had textbook configuration.

A1 segment of Anterior cerebral artery (ACA)

The variations observed in the A1 segments of right and left anterior cerebral arteries have been compiled as follows:

Table 1

Incidence of variations in Right and Left A1 segments

Type of variation

Right A1

Left A1

Total

Incidence

Absent

9 (4.18%)

3 (1.4%)

12

2.79%

Duplicated

2 (0.93%)

3 (1.4%)

5

1.16%

Hyperplastic

2 (0.93%)

-

2

0.46%

Hypoplastic

31 (14.42%)

17 (7.9%)

48

11.16%

Tortuous

2 (0.93%)

4 (1.86%)

6

1.39%

Normal

169 (78.6%)

188 (87.44%)

357

83.02%

Total

215 (100%)

215 (100%)

430

100%

In the anterior circulation, the right A1 segment was normal in 169 images (78.6%), and the left A1 was normal in 188 images (87.44%). The most frequent variation of A1 segment was hypoplasia, which was seen in 31 cases (14.42%) on the right side and 17 (7.9%) on the left (Table 1).

Anterior communicating artery (ACoA)

The ACoA was normal in 185 images (86.04%), the most common variant being the fused ACA variety (9.3%) as depicted in Table 2.

Table 2

Incidence of variations in ACoA in 215 images

Type of variation

Number of images

Incidence (%)

Absent

1

0.47

Duplication

1

0.47

Fenestrated

8

3.72

Fused ACA

20

9.3

Normal

185

86.04

Total

215

100

ACoA appeared fenestrated in eight cases, and was duplicated in one MRA. The artery was totally absent in one image.

Both duplication of ACoA and its absence were seen associated with normal pattern left A1 segment in one image each. At the same time, in five cases, fenestration of ACoA was associated with the normal left A1 segment, which was seen in 166 images and found to be statistically significant (Fisher’s two tailed p= 0.0421).

Duplication of left A1 seen in three cases was associated with fenestration of ACoA in two MRA image, while a normal left A1 (seen in 188 cases) was associated with fenestrated ACoA in five MRA, which was statistically significant (Fisher’s two tailed p=0.0034).

Figure 1

MRA image of a complete “textbook” type of circle of Willis, with complete anterior and posterior parts. ICA - internal carotid artery; MCA - middle cerebral artery; BA - basilar artery; ACoA - anterior communicating artery; PCoA - posterior communicating artery; A1 and A2 - segments of anterior cerebral artery; P1 and P2 - segments of posterior cerebral artery

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage1.png
Figure 2

MRA image showing an incomplete circle of Willis (both anterior and posterior parts). In the anterior part, A1 segment absent on right side

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage2.png
Figure 3

Incomplete circle of Willis: absent left A1 (dotted circle) in the anterior part

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage3.png

Figure 4

MRA image showing left A1 hypoplasia (*) with fused ACA

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage4.png

Figure 5

MRA image of circle of Willis showing fused ACA (*)

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage5.png

Figure 6

MRA image of circle of Willis showing duplication of right A1 (*)

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage6.png

Discussion

Over the last three hundred years, many studies and case reports have been published regarding the cerebral arterial circle or circle of Willis (CoW). The early studies were mostly cadaveric dissection studies, the largest of those being on 994 brain specimens by Riggs and Rupp7 in 1963. The introduction of radiological imaging for visualizing the circle of Willis came during the 1980s, initially using conventional cerebral angiography, and later by CT angiography and MR angiography.

Jesic et al.,8 studied the variations of the anterior part of the CoW in 1000 subjects of the Serbian population using MRA, and found the classical pattern in 643 (64.3%) cases. Anterior CoW variations were seen in 113 (11.3%), and 244 (24.4%) had posterior CoW anomalies

The ACoA was studied in 100 formalin fixed brains by Kardile et al.9 in 2013, with 38 variations reported. The most common variation was duplication (10), with absence of ACoA (8) and fusion (3).

The MR angiographic images in the present study were divided into anterior and posterior parts (Figure 7), and sub-classified into complete and incomplete variants.

Figure 7

Division of circle of Willis into anterior and posterior parts

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage7.png

The distribution of the types of variants in the anterior part of the circle of Willis, as observed in the present study, is tabulated in Table 3.

Table 3

Distribution of variants in anterior CoW in MRA

Type

A

B

C

D

E

F

Total

MR Angiograms

130 (60.46%)

1 (0.46%)

5 (2.33%)

23 (10.7%)

1 (0.46%)

55 (25.58%)

215

In the present study, the observed patterns of variations in the anterior part of the circle of Willis were classified into six patterns (Figure 8) as follows:

Figure 8

The patterns of anterior part of circle of Willis in the present studyType A: Normal complete pattern of anterior part of circle of Willis

Type B: Presence of two or more ACoAs

Type C: Duplication of unilateral A1 segment

Type D: Point fusion of both A1 segments; no visible ACoA segment

Type E: Absent or hypoplastic ACoA

Type F: Unilateral absence or hypoplasia of A1 segment

https://s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/typeset-prod-media-server/3f821427-0dac-4091-ab4f-1a2d3e0646aaimage8.png

In the above classification of the MRA images in the present study, types A-D is considered as complete, and types E-F are considered as incomplete.

In the anterior part of the circle of Willis, the normal complete pattern (type A) was observed in 60.46% of cases. However, the highest incidence of variation was seen with absence or hypoplasia (type F) of unilateral A1 segment (right and left both inclusive) in 25.88% of MRA, and this accounts for a higher incidence of incomplete anterior CoW. Fused (short segment) ACA (type D) was observed to rank as the second commonest variation with a 10.7% incidence but as the arterial pathway was essentially intact, it was categorized as complete.

Embryological and clinical correlations

In order to explain the occurrence of the variations, it is necessary to review the embryogenesis of these vessels. The development5, 6, 10, 11, 12, 13 of the cerebral arteries begins at approximately five weeks of gestation, and the primitive ICA (which arises from the dorsal aorta except the first segment which comes from the third aortic arch) is vital to the normal development of the brain and surrounding structures, being the embryologic precursor to the ACA, PCoA and MCA. In the 04 mm embryo, the carotid system supplies the forebrain and contributes to perfusion of the hindbrain through the primitive segmental arteries. In the 31-day embryo, all blood supply to the cerebrum comes from the ICA.

According to Padget,5, 6, 10 the development of anterior cerebral circle is due to the initial development of numerous arteries from the primitive ICA to supply the forebrain, followed by the regression of certain arterial segments in utero and in adult life. In foetal life, there are three ACAs connected by an anterior communicating plexus; the third (or middle ACA) and the communicating plexus should normally regress, and failure to do so results in anatomical variants such as duplication of ACA, or duplication of ACoA. Conversely, the vessel segments that should persist may abnormally regress, causing hypoplasia/ absent ACoA or hypoplasia/ absent ACA. In the event of a cerebrovascular accident (such as stroke) affecting the anterior circulation, hypoplasia or absence results in significantly reduced collateral supply, and hence leads to an increased risk for larger area of cerebral ischaemia.

Abbreviations

CoW – Circle of Willis; ICA – Internal carotid artery; ACA – Anterior cerebral artery; ACoA – Anterior communicating artery; MCA – Middle cerebral artery; BA – Basilar artery; PCA – Posterior cerebral artery; PCoA – Posterior communicating artery; MRA – Magnetic Resonance Angiography.

Conflict of Interest

None.

References

1 

S Standring AR Crossman Neuroanatomy: Vascular supply and drainage of the brainGray’s anatomy40th editionElsevier Churchill Livingstone200824754

2 

P Morris Part 2 AnatomyPractical Neuroangiography1st editionWilliams and Wilkins199787226

3 

AG Osborn Osborn’s Brain- Imaging, Pathology and Anatomy1st editionAmirsys Publishing2013

4 

P Butler AWM Mitchell JC Healy KM Hogarth J Jarosz P Butler Applied Radiological AnatomyCentral Nervous System: The Skull and Brain2nd editionCambridge University Press2012136

5 

DH Padget WE Dandy Intracranial arterial aneurysmsThe circle of Willis. Its embryology and anatomyComstock Publishing CompanyNew York19486790

6 

DH Padget The development of the cranial arteries in the human embryoContrib Embryol19483220761

7 

HE Riggs Variation in Form of Circle of WillisArch Neurol196381810.1001/archneur.1963.00460010024002

8 

A Jesic S Torbica S Maric S Popovic D Kozic Anatomic variations of the anterior portion of the circle of Willis: an MR angiography studyCurr Top Neurol Psychiat Relat Discip2011XIX916

9 

PB Kardile JM Ughade SV Pandit MN Ughade Anatomical variations of anterior communicating arteryJ Clin Diagn Res201371226614

10 

DH Padget Designation of the embryonic intersegmental arteries in reference to the vertebral artery and subclavian stemAnatomical Rec195411933495610.1002/ar.1091190306

11 

SK Battacharji EC Hutchinson AJ Mccall The circle of Willis- the incidence of developmental anomalies in normal and infarcted brainsBrain196790474758

12 

DB Moffat The embryology of the arteries of the brainAnn R Coll Surg Engl19623036882

13 

D B Moffat The development of posterior cerebral arteryJournal Anat Physiol954



jats-html.xsl

© This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (creativecommons.org) which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.


  • Article highlights
  • Article tables
  • Article images

Article History

Received : 01-01-2021

Accepted : 10-01-2021

Available online : 12-04-2021


View Article

PDF File   Full Text Article


Copyright permission

Get article permission for commercial use

Downlaod

PDF File   XML File   ePub File


Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

Article DOI

https://doi.org/10.18231/j.ijcap.2021.008


Article Metrics






Article Access statistics

Viewed: 105

PDF Downloaded: 57